Bison swept by Muskingum

Bison swept by Muskingum

Andrew Woodley, Sports Information Director

BETHANY, W.Va. (April 23) - The Bethany College baseball team 


  • Game 1 Final: Muskingum 8, Bethany 5 (Box Score)
  • Game 2 Final: Muskingum 15, Bethany 6 (Box Score)
  • Records: Bethany 8-19 | Muskingum 14-19
  • Location: Bethany Park | Bethany, West Virginia

GAME 1: Muskingum 8, Bethany 5


  • Bethany built up a 4-0 lead with a pair of two-run innings in the first and second. The big hit came in the form of a two-RBI double by senior Kelaen Welch (Follansbee, W.Va./Brooke) in the second inning.
  • Muskingum managed to slice the lead in half in the third inning despite zero hits. The Muskies loaded the bases with a walk, hit-by-pitch and an error, before scoring on a bases loaded walk to make the score 4-1.
  • Bethany allowed a second run while turning a 4-6-3 double play and escaped further damage with a fly ball out to strand a runner at third and maintain a 4-2 lead.
  • Junior Tyler Frazee (Markleysburg, Pa./Uniontown) led the bottom of the third off with a double, before freshman Kyle Goodwin (Parkersburg, W.Va./Parkersburg) helped rebuild the Bison lead to three, 5-2, with a RBI-single with two outs.
  • Muskingum inched closer with runs in the fourth and fifth innings to make the score 5-4 entering the seventh.
  • The Muskies got a lead-off home run to tie the game and scored three more runs with the help of a throwing error, sacrifice fly and a two-out single.
  • The Bison managed to send the tying-run to the plate with two runners on and two outs, but an infield ground ball ended the game. 


  • Senior pitcher Andrew Gilliland (Gahanna, Ohio/Bishop Hartley) pitched 4.1 innings and allowed four runs (two earned) on five hits to earn a no-decision.
  • Welch was the team's top batter with two hits and two RBI.
  • Bethany was charged with three errors in the loss, while Bison pitchers yielded only three earned runs. 

GAME 2: Muskingum 15, Bethany 6


  • The Muskies scored all 15 of its runs in three innings to send the Bison to a two-game sweep.
  • After two scoreless frames, Muskingum struck for four runs on five hits to establish a lead.
  • The Muskies put Bethany away with a seven-run fourth inning that was aided by a Bison miscue.
  • Bethany's bats came alive in the fifth inning with three runs on five hits, including RBI base hits by sophomore Kevin Marthinsen (Pittsburgh, Pa./Upper St. Clair) and junior Jake Stemmerich (Greensburg, Pa./Greater Latrobe) to make the score 11-3.
  • Muskingum managed to extend its lead to 15-3 with four runs in the seventh inning.
  • Bethany did not go down quietly, as Marthinsen and Stemmerich delivered two more RBI base hits. Marthinsen singled in one run, before he was brought home when Stemmerich belted a two-run home run over the right field fence to bring the score to 15-6.


  • Stemmerich finished with a home run, double and four RBI in the game, while Marthinsen added two RBI singles.


  • The Bison travel to Pittsburgh on Wednesday, April 25 to play a non-conference game at La Roche at 4 p.m.
  • Bethany also announced today that it will make-up its conference doubleheader at Westminster on Friday, April 27 at 1 p.m.